Peterson`s Fish in Syracuse

Peterson`s Fish in Syracuse
3.5 / 5
50 reviews

1009 S Huntington St, Syracuse, IN 46567-1936, Syracuse

Overview

Cuisine
  • American
  • Seafood

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

What are their hours and when is all you can eat Mondays and Tuesdays

Hours are 11 - 8. AYCE served all day Monday and Tuesday

Are you open Christmas Eve??

Better call them

Are you open between Christmas and New year? I drive over 7 hours to eat here. Next time I plan on coming up is that week. This is my number one stop!

It's best to call for their holiday hours .

Do you have gift certificates?

Yes

Someone said you won't be opening another place at the old Nappanee bar after all. Is this true?

No

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Peterson`s Fish
BF
Brett Freund
google
11.21.2024
5/5

Did was fresh and hot, service was great plus kids are well.

Peterson`s Fish
MH
Michael Haines
google
07.21.2018
4/5

Not bad at all. Decent atmosphere and food, good service.

Peterson`s Fish
KB
Kristi Bowers
google
06.25.2018
5/5

Love their prime rib and their all you can eat fish!

Peterson`s Fish
bg
brent grimm
google
06.22.2018
3/5

Had been looking forward to trying this place but was disappointed. $20 for AYCE and soup salad bar with a beverage. My mom's baked potato was brown...appeared to be a reheat? Yuck. Fish was bland and half of it was overcooked. Server was nice enough though. I should have had a good steak somewhere at this price point - especially considering the quality of the fish.

Peterson`s Fish
CI
Cheryl Ide
google
06.21.2018
5/5

A joy to dine here, fish dinner, scrumptious!Wait staff very personable

Peterson`s Fish
KB
Kylee Baughman
google
06.10.2018
5/5

We have visited Peterson's several times and the food is great

Peterson`s Fish
JW
Jeanette Waltz
google
06.03.2018
3/5

This place is not cheap. Tenderloin is 739 fries are a 150 more a soda 249 a king cut prime rib was 26 and change. The food was good but not that good.

Peterson`s Fish
DM
Durwin Miller
google
04.22.2018
5/5

Great food, AYCE fish and shrimp was good and reasonably priced.

Peterson`s Fish
DW
Duane W
google
01.27.2018
5/5

The fish was awesome!! Good size portions and very delicious. We had the hush puppies and they were delicious as well. Staff were very friendly and helpful. Not a fancy place but great food. Will be going back soon!

Peterson`s Fish
BJ
Brandon Jackson
google
01.17.2018
5/5

Best fried fish around

Peterson`s Fish
HS
Helen Schooley
google
01.09.2018
5/5

great need to have bake potatoes all the times

Peterson`s Fish
LF
Leroy Fouts
google
01.03.2018
4/5

Good food and price. Nice and friendly staff.

Peterson`s Fish
IW
Ida Wallen
google
11.23.2017
4/5

We arrived 20 minutes prior to closing, but we're here by friendly staff. The food is delicious!! Try the bread pudding. It is so yummy??

Peterson`s Fish
SC
Stacy Coy
google
11.09.2017
5/5

Always good food, service and atmosphere.

Peterson`s Fish
VH
Verna Hicks
google
07.15.2017
5/5

Food was great served in an appropriate time service was good restaurant was clean and family friendly

Peterson`s Fish
DR
Dawn Runkle
google
07.04.2017
5/5

Lovely salad bar and fabulous fried fish on 1 dollar to add as special on valentines day. Soup was delicious. Cole slaw not how i prefer though. Personal preference I guess

Peterson`s Fish
MC
Martin Cabela
google
06.27.2017
5/5

Unique local fish restaurant. Friendly service and very clean.Decorations include highly polished antique outboard motors. Atmosphere is family style with a soup bar and salad bar. Tried the Our fish dinner which is Pollack. Very good. Liked the clam chowder, fries and coke slaw.

Peterson`s Fish
SB
Sharon Bollenbacher
google
05.07.2017
2/5

Nothing special. Did not care for the clam chowder.

Peterson`s Fish
MS
Morgan Shields
google
04.04.2017
5/5

My family loves this place! I am not a huge fish fan but I like their other options. Their tartar sauce is my favorite!

Peterson`s Fish
DM
Dave McIntyre
google
03.18.2017
5/5

Best fish around! Sweet tartar sauce, just how I like it.

Peterson`s Fish
DM
Donald Mumaw
google
03.04.2017
5/5

Excellent food. Great service.

Peterson`s Fish
AC
Austin Chilcutt
google
02.18.2017
5/5

This is the only place I get Fish from in Syracuse...or anywhere for that matter! For $10.69 you can get a lb of the delicious, flaky, buttery fish, 2 of those amazing pieces of bread, tartar sauce & butter. It's a good dinner alone or to share, me and my brother split the cost usually

Peterson`s Fish
lf
leroy fouts
google
02.09.2017
3/5

Good fish and very friendly staff

Peterson`s Fish
PH
Pamela Huffer
google
01.25.2017
4/5

Love fish, waitress and greeter were excellent. Love the food, but salad bar could be bigger. But o will go back for the fish.

Peterson`s Fish
MJ
Mason Johnson
google
01.23.2017
5/5

Best clam chowder in miles. Highly recommend

Peterson`s Fish
JC
John Castaneda
google
11.25.2016
5/5

Good food with good friends . Food was great but fried too long . Service was very good . Will be back . Tartar sauce was way too sweet.

Peterson`s Fish
JB
John Buenger
google
11.24.2016
5/5

Best salad bar in town and now they serve alcohol!

Peterson`s Fish
DL
Debra Lanning
google
11.07.2016
4/5

Very good local restaurant

Peterson`s Fish
MR
Michael Rider
google
11.07.2016
5/5

Very good fish and the salad bar was wonderful.

Peterson`s Fish
jm
jennifer miller
google
11.06.2016
4/5

Love the fish, and love the decorations they have, especially the front door as you walk in.

Peterson`s Fish
g!
gatorbrayden22 !
google
10.01.2016
3/5

Had to wait a long time for our food. The food still tasted good. This place is good for people that have a good patience but also enjoy fish, shrimp, and burgers.

Peterson`s Fish
RC
Robert Clawson
google
09.20.2016
4/5

They have good food. The staff is usually happy. The salad bar is pretty good but the desert bar has only a couple of things on it. The all you can eat fish is always very good. A little pricey but good.

Peterson`s Fish
AH
Anita Holderman
google
09.14.2016
4/5

Had a good meal with friends. We all had the all you can eat fish. Really good.

Peterson`s Fish
LA
Luke A
google
09.06.2016
5/5

Really good. The fish, clams, and french fries were all great!

Peterson`s Fish
SK
Susan K
google
08.14.2016
5/5

Great service and amazing fish! Love there Clam Chowder soup.

Peterson`s Fish
HT
Holly Teddy
google
08.06.2016
5/5

Great place for fish, delicious food, mask worn and social distancing was observed.

Peterson`s Fish
BB
Beth Bugg
google
07.27.2016
5/5

Good service and food, no salad bar right now.

Peterson`s Fish
PV
Patricia Vanderveer
google
07.10.2016
4/5

Great food, reasonable prices, and wonderful "howetown" atmosphere!

Peterson`s Fish
KB
Kent Briar
google
06.23.2016
5/5

Best darn fish around. The service is great. The salad boat is full of good salads. Best bread pudding around.

Peterson`s Fish
DC
David Coe
google
06.15.2016
5/5

Always good food and service when we go. Best fish around! Definitely worth the stop.

Peterson`s Fish
JS
Johnny Salisbury
google
05.25.2016
5/5

We got the all you can eat fish special. And it was great. The fish was great and our waiter was right on the ball. Every time we wanted more she came right out with hot baskets!

Peterson`s Fish
KJ
Kenneth J Wonder
google
04.14.2016
5/5

It's so nice to go to Petersons. Everyone is friendly. The salad bar is great and the fish is always good!

Peterson`s Fish
JW
Jamie White
google
04.04.2016
5/5

Amazing food with a great atmosphere and very friendly staff. Salad and soup bar are always delicious. Great assortment of food. The best fish around. We try to go at least once a week.

Peterson`s Fish
CD
Caleb Davis
google
03.11.2016
4/5

Great fish ,fast service

Peterson`s Fish
OP
One Person
google
02.24.2016
4/5

Salad bar was good. Food was a little salty for me. I had trouble eating my chicken. To their defense their specialty is fish. They have all you can eat fish on Monday night. I did not try that.

Peterson`s Fish
SL
Steven Laureys
google
02.07.2016
5/5

Best fish and tartar sauce in the State. This has been a long time family favorite and never disappoints!

Peterson`s Fish
DP
Debra Pierce
google
01.27.2016
5/5

Wonderful! I had the fish and my husband had the coconut shrimp. The clam chowder was fantastic!

Peterson`s Fish
BR
Beth Reeves101fs
google
01.22.2016
5/5

They have awesome fish very good food

Peterson`s Fish
JE
Justin Easton
google
01.21.2016
4/5

Peterson fish is a great place to eat when you want quality fried catfish, a large salad bar and the absolute best clam chowder. It's a favorite spot for the family and you can't get much better. Service is usually great and the bathrooms are clean.

Peterson`s Fish
JS
Jonathan Shaw
google
01.12.2016
4/5

I. Love. Their. Fish. Go. Now!

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 15745285000

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!